Address: 4 Old Turnpike Rd. Convent Station, NJ
AKT Rating: 4 WOWS!
- Tea Selection: 4 WOWS!
- Scones: 4 WOWS!
- Finger Sandwiches: 3 WOWS!
- Pastries: 4 WOWS!
- Menu Variety: 5 WOWS!
- Ambience: 4 WOWS!
- Price: PRICED FAIRLY!
When I had arrived at The Cozy Cupboard, all I saw on the outside was a house. But, when I went inside, it was a beautiful area with the perfect lighting and lots of tables that could fit many people. They service was also amazing as they greeted us warmly, and came to check in on us every so often.
The selection of tea wasn’t very wide, but, the tea itself was very high quality and I enjoyed that very much. The scones were very big, and quite warm, but very delicious. They had given us loads of preserves, and being that one huge clotted cream fan, I obviously loaded up on a lot of clotted cream. The finger sandwiches were actually not as delicious as I had expected. I really had one favourite out of all the ones they gave me, (but it’s not personal at all, I just happen to enjoy one sandwich more than the others). It was the sandwich that included the cucumber and the cream. Onto desserts! They had given us the options of choosing different cakes and pies. (For example, cheesecake, chocolate, key lime, etc.) I chose a cheesecake, and to be honest, it wasn’t amazing, but it also wasn’t terrible. It somehow tasted as if it had a hint of cinnamon.
The food variety was very wide. I remember one of my family members getting a salad and a soup. Looking on the website, there were also quiches and crepes. Of course the price of all these foods were quite fair for the quality.